I’m in the middle of the Cell Unit now. We’ve already established the structure and function of the cell membrane and are now working on the structure and function of the nucleus. The Cheek Cell Lab went off without a hitch and the post-lab discussion revealed that my kids remembered that the nucleus was the “control center” of the cell and it contained DNA. One class remembered that the letters for DNA were A,T,C,G. At this point we transitioned to the DNAi.org Activity about DNA structure. Next year I think I will add in a DNA Extraction Lab in between the Cheek Cell Lab and the DNAi.org Activity. I find that students “get” DNA better after they have seen actual DNA. In the past I’ve used a strawberry DNA Extraction from the Exploring Life Textbook by Campbell, Williamson et. al. One of the other teachers in the department does an extraction using cheek cells and a “mouthwash” solution. I think I’ll try to combine these two labs together. I really like the idea of extracting DNA from cheek cells after the kids observed their own cheek cells under the microscope. The kids will get a macro view of DNA from the abstraction and we can then transition to a micro view of DNA with the DNAi.org Activity. Later this Spring or in the Summer I’ll purchase the DNA model kits depending on when the district frees up some money.
Categories
-
Recent Posts
- Grading September 28, 2016
- Week 2 – Modeling Biology Year 2 September 15, 2014
- Week 1 – Modeling Biology Year 2 September 6, 2014
- Grading Presentation March 16, 2014
- DNA Extraction January 4, 2014
Archives
Tag Could
What I’m tweeting about
- .@jorja_hooper It was great running into you today. You made my afternoon. I hope all is well in your world! 11 months ago
- RT @gcschmit: This year, instead of asking students, “Do you have any questions?”, I’m saying, “Ask me two questions.” And then I wait. The… 1 year ago
- RT @AP_Trevor: The 2018 AP Biology scores: 5: 7.1%; 4: 21.5%; 3: 32.9%; 2: 28.5%; 1: 10%. This year, there were more strong students, and… 1 year ago
- RT @aserkin: We still have some open spots for our 2018 summer workshops. Best PD experiences I’ve ever had. Sign up. #modchem #modbio h… 1 year ago
- RT @ziegeran: What if PD across the system modeled our vision for learning? #edchat #leadupchat #edadmin #satchat #bfc530 https://t.co/e7bg… 2 years ago
These folks say interesting stuff…
- MDOE SciTech Framework
- The Optimist
- Kate's Krew
- Just Another Teacher in Maine
- Gary G. Abud, Jr.
- TEACHING|chemistry
- Science teacher
- Wisdom Begins with Wonder
- Ecology of Education | Games in the Classroom
- What It's Like on the Inside
- Granted, and...
- Science Education on the Edge
- Lab Out Loud
- The Art of Teaching Science
- Science for All
- Physics! Blog!
- Action-Reaction
- Practical Theory
Advertisements
There are many activities in Biology that I feel connected to and thus tend to hang about beyond their usefulness; DNA extraction was one of them. On one hand, it’s really cool and kids have fun doing it. On the other hand, it doesn’t really move a student’s conceptual understanding of how cells work and it doesn’t illuminate any secrets about the structure or function of DNA.
When I encounter these activities I ask myself a series of questions: what is the model students are constructing? How does this activity aid students in constructing the model? What will students do and what questions will they be answering? Are there opportunities for students to answer the questions in multiple ways or is there a set procedure to follow with a predetermined ending?
In the end, I found DNA extraction was not worth the time. Perhaps you come to a different conclusion; I would love to hear about how you make it more meaningful!
Rebecca, I was looking at the original post to compose a reply on the BIOMOD listserv when I found your response. You said part of what I wanted to say – much better than I could manage to say it. I particularly like the set of questions and I think they could be more generally helpful. Would you or Ryan mind posting your response on the BIOMOD listserv to try and open up a more general discussion?
Anita, I will add to the list serve, I am having technical issues posting and have reached out for assistance. Thanks!
I posted your response without your name attached indicating that Anita asked one of us to post it.
I’d really like to get on this BIOMOD list serve. I am very interested in modeling Biology. Twitter is @mrjfricker
Hi Jacob,
Thanks for the response and the posts on Twitter I enjoy seeing what you are doing. I found this link on the AMTA website for joining the list serves
http://modelinginstruction.org/teachers/collaboration/
I’d look forward to seeing some more activity on the BIOMOD list serve.